Why CEOs Shouldn't Hide Their Toughest Leadership Chapter

Career AdviceCareer TransitionsLeadership StrategiesCulture RiskBoard and CEO AdvisoryDevelopment and Transition
記事アイコン Article
Portrait of Efe Ekhaese, leadership advisor at Russell Reynolds Associates
Efe Ekhaese
11月 17, 2026
6 記事アイコン
Career AdviceCareer TransitionsLeadership StrategiesCulture RiskBoard and CEO AdvisoryDevelopment and Transition
Executive Summary
A flawless CEO career won't always secure your next appointment. Boards are looking for leaders who can explain how setbacks shaped their leadership.
rra-article-why-ceos-shouldnt-hide.jpg

 

When I work with experienced CEOs preparing for their next appointment, I often see them work hard to make every tenure on their CV sound like an unequivocal success. It’s understandable. They worry that acknowledging a role that didn't go to plan will damage their credibility. They fear it signals poor judgment, underperformance, or that they're somehow less ready for their next appointment.

 

But in my experience, trying to smooth over a difficult chapter can actually make your leadership story less compelling.

Few CEO tenures are perfect. Boards know that. Most have seen markets shift overnight, strategies unravel, mergers fail to deliver the expected value, and organizations change direction in ways no leader could have anticipated. They are rarely looking for executives with an unblemished record.

In fact, I often find boards are far more interested in understanding why a role became challenging, what the leader learned from it, and how they would approach the same situation differently today.

 

Boards know that leadership journeys are rarely linear

The reality is that leadership takes place in complex environments where many factors sit outside an individual's control. A role can become significantly more difficult—or even unsuccessful—for reasons that have little to do with capability.

Perhaps the previous opportunity you accepted wasn't exactly as it had been described during the interview process. Maybe you joined expecting one culture or one level of organizational maturity, only to discover something very different once you arrived.

Perhaps market conditions changed dramatically halfway through your tenure. A strategy that looked entirely appropriate at the beginning of your appointment became far harder to execute as customer demand shifted, new competitors emerged, or economic conditions deteriorated.

Sometimes the challenge is more personal. You and the board may have developed fundamentally different views about where the business should go. Strategic disagreement at senior levels is not unusual, particularly when organizations face significant disruption or challenge.

And sometimes, despite your experience and best intentions, you simply make the wrong call. Every CEO has made decisions they would approach differently with the benefit of hindsight. Leadership requires judgment under uncertainty, and no one gets every important decision right.

 

Why self-reflection matters more than perfection

When I help boards identify their next CEO, I pay close attention to how executives talk about the more difficult chapters of their leadership journey. Do they spend the conversation blaming market conditions, difficult board directors, or organizational politics? Or do they demonstrate genuine reflection about their own contribution, what they learned, and how the experience changed them as a leader?

Boards are not expecting you to have all the answers. They are, however, looking for leaders who can evaluate themselves honestly. The strongest executives are comfortable saying something like:

"At the time, I believed this was the right strategic decision. Looking back, I underestimated these risks. If I were leading that situation again, I would approach it differently because..."

That response demonstrates maturity. It shows you can process setbacks constructively rather than becoming defensive.

We know from our research, that self-awareness of your strengths, limitations, motivations, and potential derailers is one of the foundations of effective leadership. Leaders who possess this level of insight are generally much better equipped to navigate unfamiliar situations because they understand where they add value, where they need support, and the environments in which they are most likely to thrive. That is often far more reassuring to a board than hearing a series of success stories.

Taking the time to reflect and continue to hone your self-awareness muscle is critical at the CEO level, when there are fewer people willing—or able—to challenge your thinking.

As one CEO told us: "Knowing oneself is the foundation on which leaders should build everything else. Having a strong self-conception helps leaders keep focused on what matters to them and their organization, even through extreme change."

 

The best CEOs never stop being students

The other quality that boards are often looking for is a high learning quotient. The most effective leaders maintain a student mentality throughout their careers. They remain curious, actively seek different perspectives, and continue questioning their own assumptions long after reaching senior positions.

The reason boards look for this is because one of the greatest risks for experienced CEOs is believing that past success guarantees future success. Leaders can begin to rely too heavily on familiar approaches because those approaches have worked before. They draw on experience instead of remaining open to new thinking. Over time, their learning curve begins to flatten. That creates real risk in today's business environment.

Organizations are operating in a landscape defined by constant change. The CEOs who continue to grow are those who treat every experience—including unsuccessful ones—as another opportunity to learn. That's why I encourage you not to see difficult leadership chapters as something to hide. Instead, think about what they reveal about your development as a leader.

Can you explain what happened with honesty?

Can you demonstrate what you learned?

Can you articulate how that experience changed your judgment?

Ultimately, boards already know you've led organizations. They're now trying to understand how you'll lead the next one. Your ability to reflect honestly on previous roles gives them confidence that your judgment has evolved alongside your experience.

Authors

Efe Ekaese is a leadership advisor at Russell Reynolds Associates. He is based in Florida.