This paper is based on a series of roundtable discussions held with CEOs, CHROs and Operation Leaders of manufacturing organizations in India; conducted across Mumbai, Pune and New Delhi
It took humans over two centuries to progress from the introduction of mechanization to mass production and then to automation. Today, less than 50 years from the third industrial revolution, we are already talking about the efficiencies and new business opportunities that organizations are generating from the fourth one - Industry 4.0 (I4.0), a collaboration of hardware and software to develop smart factories.
Through a series of roundtable discussions with CEOs, CHROs and operations leaders from a mix of Indian companies and MNCs with significant operations in India, we looked at transforming manufacturing in the era of I4.0. The question on everyone’s mind: Is it a necessity or a luxury? We also tried to identify some of the grassroot challenges these organizations face in implementing I4.0 in manufacturing and the implications for leadership and other organizational enablers.
While there is no doubt that MNCs are leveraging their experiences and successes from developed markets in implementing I4.0 in their manufacturing operations in India, some of the India-based manufacturing companies have also made significant strides in adopting technology in their manufacturing processes. Companies rightly understand that investing in technology is key to their survival. In the unforgiving marketplace, successful companies are expected to control every step in the value chain. From a quality and cost perspective, they need to have connected systems to ensure consistency and responsiveness. In our discussions, the need to delight the customer was seen as the strongest business case for investing in technology.
Nevertheless, in India, many of the labor-intensive sectors, such as automotive, industrial goods and other heavy manufacturing, remain far behind in digitizing and modernizing their manufacturing facilities. Many of them still believe in exhausting low-cost options available rather than implementing high-cost technologies. In a survey conducted by RRA,over 62 percent of the organizations mentioned that they are still at the third industrial revolution in terms of technology journey in their manufacturing – and will not move to I4.0 till they exhaust the benefits from I3.0.
Trends impacting the manufacturing sector
The introduction of new technologies – IoT, AI, ML, 3D printing, etc. - is already disrupting the manufacturing industry. Irrespective of sector, customer-centricity is the need of the hour for every organization. With increase in quality consciousness, customers are making better-informed decisions, which in turn is putting the pressure on manufacturers and the larger supply chain to drive innovation. Organizations are witnessing the emergence of in-house digital analytics and innovation capabilities. Initiatives such as cloud-based planning and smart manufacturing are being implemented to create use cases for cost efficiency. The speed at which the new technologies are disrupting manufacturing pose critical questions for the today’s leaders around the right leadership competencies to drive change, and what specific skills and roles are needed to execute transformation and robust organization culture to ensure sustainable change.
We tried to understand the roadblocks associated with embracing technology in India. Some of the commonly discussed topics were:
Of these, training/ knowledge gaps and lack of the right culture to absorb I4.0 changes came out as the biggest hurdles for transforming manufacturing in India.
However, given the competitive dynamics, embracing technology is no longer an option, it is a necessity. Fundamentally, we believe that technology is here to stay, and manufacturing companies need to figure out a way to embrace this efficiently.
Change in leadership competencies required for today’s manufacturing organizations
The operations leader job specification has changed significantly over the recent past. Traditionally manufacturing organizations have always looked for technical acumen in their operations leaders. Today, leading companies speak about commercial and financial acumen in the same breath. Organization leaders at the forefront of I4.0 are exhibiting greater openness to new ideas, and therefore an increased tolerance to failures. With the changing ecosystem, many organizations are also trying to pinpoint the broader competencies they will require of leaders in the near future.
Our research on senior operations/ supply chain leaders in manufacturing environments points to four key leadership competencies that define transformational leaders in these organizations –
Senior level operations roles are increasingly being seen as
industry agnostic – and more as a combination of the above competencies. There are numerous examples of leaders coming from various backgrounds and driving transformational growth in traditional manufacturing organizations. As we define them, they could be
technologists (R&D/ technology experts),
operation experts (know the pulse of the shop-floor),
engineering leaders (strong project/ change management with technology expertise) or even
commercial champions (strong customer market orientation).
Organizational enablers to drive change
I4.0 is a journey and not a binary switch. Organizations do not just need a grand unifying digital vision but also need a plan to address that vision through a series of actionable steps.
Transforming Manufacturing in the Era of Industry 4.0
Implications for Organizations & Leadership
The Industrial Revolutions that took place in 18th and 19th centuries marked a shift to powered, specialpurpose machinery, factories and mass production. This led to an availability of increased volume and variety of manufactured goods and an improvement in economic, cultural and social conditions of people. Beginning in the 1970s, the third industrial revolution introduced a shift from analog to digital technologies, electronics and information technology led to automation of production. Each of these industrial revolutions represented profound change and major societal transformation. While it took over 100 years for the third industrial revolution to take birth, today a fourth industrial revolution – I4.0 – is underway in less than 50 years. I4.0 builds upon the automation and enhances it with smart and autonomous systems that talk to each other, fueled by data and machine learning. It includes a combination of cloud, IoT, robotics, augmented reality, additive manufacturing, big data & analytics, and cybersecurity. These new technologies that are transforming industrial production promise greater efficiencies and require a change in traditional production relationships among suppliers, producers and customers.
While the early adopters of advanced manufacturing and AI-driven technology report positive returns and new opportunities for growth, the adoption of technology still remains low across industries and regions. According to Russell Reynolds Associates’ Global Digital Pulse Survey 2018, only 35 percent of respondents from the industrial sector and 45 percent from healthcare said their businesses have been significantly transformed by digital technology. In a similar poll of a small set of Indian leaders, 62 percent said that they have not moved beyond the third industrial revolution. The low adoption rates raise questions about what is hindering manufacturing organizations from moving into I4.0. Based on our research, a key factor appears to be, the leadership competencies at CEO/HR/Manufacturing level to drive change. In today’s world it has become imperative to understand organizational enablers including skill sets required and new roles emerging to execute such transformations. At the same time leadership needs to ensure conduciveness of the manufacturing culture to bring about a sustainable change.
Since India is home to the supply chain operations of many multinational corporations, there is an increasing interest in seeing how Indian manufacturing is able to adopt I4.0 technologies and raise their performance standards. Plus, sitting in India, these manufacturing nodes get to see how their respective global organizations are leveraging tools to better compare production footprints, cost of delivery and raw materials across their nodes globally – hence, there is continuous competitive pressure from other geographies to be more relevant cost and quality-wise within their global supply chains. To that extent, there is an increased focus on the Indian manufacturing sector to drive transformational changes to remain competitive in the global market place.
When we surveyed a small group of CHROs and COOs across 30 different manufacturing organizations in India, around 62 percent of the companies claimed to be still at the third industrial revolution while the remaining were at different stages of their journey towards a I4.0 vision already.
Trends impacting the manufacturing sector
The technology trends that have disrupted businesses across value chains, are now increasingly focusing on driving impact in manufacturing as well. These include the Internet of Things (the connected factory), Automation/ Artificial Intelligence (robotics), Augmented Reality (real-time information & material flows), and Additive Manufacturing (3D printing). These are further being influenced by various business model disruptions that have come into traditional manufacturing businesses. For example, today’s manufacturing businesses are increasingly working backwards from their target customer markets to drive innovation. There is increasing emphasis on enterprise in-house digital analytics and innovation capabilities, enhanced cost efficiency and value achieved by initiatives such as cloud-based planning, smart manufacturing, etc. Further, there is ever-present push to accelerate globalization of manufacturing enabled by digital networks and ecosystems.
The above trends are forcing organizations to ask the following questions of their boards & CXOs –
However, Indian companies – both multi-national & local companies face multiple challenges in driving this transformation in a highly labor-intensive manufacturing environment in India.
What Leadership Competencies are needed for today’s manufacturing organizations?
Given the above trends, there is a clear need to look at senior leadership in manufacturing-based businesses differently from the traditional set of competencies that are usually used to measure them. Based on some of the research that RRA has done on the cohort of senior operations/ supply chain leaders in manufacturing environments, these were some of the key leadership competencies that stood out for high-performing leaders in these organizations –
Financial acumen used to be a primary consideration for leaders (it is quite difficult to imagine a CEO who is not on top of his or her numbers). Today, companies give technology acumen the same weight. Today’s top performing operations leaders are no longer just “shopfloor managers”. Given the customer-centricity factor, these leaders bring strong commercial acumen with deep knowledge of end-use consumer markets. They cannot afford to be too siloed in their approach, and hence, are keen observers of their organizational capabilities internally so as to pro-actively identify gaps that need to be plugged for driving transformation. These can be either through leadership development and training for their internal teams; or alternatively by bringing the right skillsets via external technology & change partners.
This does not constrain where your future leaders might come from. There are examples of leaders coming from a variety of backgrounds and experiences to get to top leadership roles in manufacturing companies where they have delivered transformational value to their companies in the I4.0 space.
The change of guard: internal vs external talent?
In India, an engineering graduate in a traditional manufacturing sector would go on to become the manufacturing head. It was assumed that internal candidates knew the organization better than anyone else could; there was no concept of diversity. It was taken for granted that an external candidate does not know the ecosystem while the internal candidate would take people along.
However today, the ecosystem is changing drastically and what most clients are trying to solve for is the set of competencies that would be required in the near future versus the present. Today the walls are breaking, and companies need more networked people with exposure across functions. Competencies are not industry specific. For example, the pharma industry is very quality focused; the same is now true for F&B as well.
Some of the more mature players are no longer looking for talent from within the industry itself, even at the senior level for professionals managing sizeable revenues. The trend is to look for professionals with exposure to innovative practices and out-of-thebox thinking. The younger generation is considered to be highly networked (culturally they are more connected, know how to reach out given the benefits of technology). Such external disruptions are pushing the management to look at professionals from other sectors with greater learning agility. As a result, your leadership pipeline can come from outside your company or industry as well.
Organizational enablers to drive change
New skillsets are at the center of transformation; driving alignment and collaboration across the enterprise. New job descriptions are being written across traditional manufacturing organizations, so as to introduce new skillsets into the teams that will lead the transformation.
The role of Learning & Development is equally important. The trend of investing in training is making a comeback but there is now a need for customized training to establish Centers of Excellence/ academies and build future capabilities. For example, the last technology wave saw the introduction of ERP, but it took years for organizations to learn how to fully utilize it. In this new technology wave, organizations need to develop capabilities in advance. Focusing on only technology without understanding realworld requirements and limitations will create implementation challenges. The technical and functional gap needs to be bridged.
This effort is not only internal but also involves external ecosystem partners. Over the last 5-10 years, quality consciousness has increased and that should support the external ecosystem (distributors, retailers) to better incorporate technology. For example, in the auto industry, vendor audit goes up to the tertiary level. That is enforcing some form of traceability right from the tertiary level to the final customer. Given the real time impact that technology has and the fact that informed choices are being made, pressure on suppliers would be high in terms of quality, cost efficiency and technology will only add as an enabler to meet this goal. Top companies have dedicated vendor development programs where they work with suppliers to upscale their capabilities.
Sustainable cultural change is the other major organizational enabler required for manufacturing organizations to enter I4.0. In India especially, manufacturing has traditionally been highly labor intensive, resulting in large distributed workforces – making cultural change an even larger challenge.
Embracing technology is no longer an option due to the competitive forces in every industry today. Hence, it is important for leaders to assume that technology is here to stay, and to see how you are leverage it for your business needs.
Given this, we need to ask the following two questions to begin with –
SANJAY KAPOOR is a member of the firm’s Industrial and Natural Resources Sectors. He is based in New Delhi.
PUNEET KALRAis a member of the firm’s Technology practice. He is based in New Delhi.
VIJURAJ ERANAZHATHis a member of the firm’s Industrial and Natural Resources and Global Supply Chain Sectors. He is based in Mumbai.
SHAMA GUPTAis a member of the firm’s Industrial and Natural Resources Sectors. She is based in New Delhi.